JBKW / Overcreativity

Holistic Keeping Practices, Empowering Keepers, Avoiding Pitfalls, Busting "Hoarding" Misconceptions, Having Fun

β€Ί Home β€Ί Articles β€Ί Freedom Hypothesis: Most If Not All Cases Of "Hoarding" or Dysfunction In Possessions Arise Out Of Being Unfree β€Ί

Freedom Hypothesis: Most If Not All Cases Of "Hoarding" or Dysfunction In Possessions Arise Out Of Being Unfree


Let me ask you a simple question - assuming you are personally concerned with dysfunction in your possessions -

Are you free, as in freedom ?

Are you free to make your own choices with everything in your personal life - to arrange your space the way you prefer, to allocate time and money how you prefer - or is it under strain and/or constraint from someone or something else - limiting your choices, giving you orders, claiming resources ? I'm not talking about the usual "suspects" like job, law, physics... Nor am I talking about the usual talking points from the "experts" on "hoarding" - supposed "emotional attachment", "difficulty making decisions", "difficulty discarding" - that's skipping to the end and oversimplifying it.

I have a hypothesis -

Most, if not all, cases of what they call "hoarding", a "mental illness", and what I call simply Dysfunction in Possessions, are going to involve people who are unfree.

Even for people living alone, this will be the case - including upbringing and imperatives given to them by their parents, peers, society at large, the "experts" on "hoarding", etc.

I may be wrong about this, but I'm probably right.

To be discussed.