JBKW / Overcreativity

Holistic Keeping Practices, Empowering Keepers, Avoiding Pitfalls, Busting "Hoarding" Misconceptions, Having Fun

β€Ί Home β€Ί Articles β€Ί Hypothesis - what if, in many / most / all cases, including examples in the book ( which appears to check out so far ) of what is labeled "Hoarding Disorder", is not a primary mental illness, but a predictable systemic failure caused by any combination of - β€Ί

Hypothesis - what if, in many / most / all cases, including examples in the book ( which appears to check out so far ) of what is labeled "Hoarding Disorder", is not a primary mental illness, but a predictable systemic failure caused by any combination of -


* skills gap ( handling ideation, flows, projects, organizing possessions )

* resource starvation ( cf Traps, Supertrap )

* coercive environment ( "nagging and yelling", prevalent in the books ) - at least, in a meaningful subset of cases under consideration ?

* Runaway Mental Processes ( RMPs )

* otherwise rational, internally consistent logic, with the original causes of a different nature

* other factors medical or non-medical, without loss of generality

This checks out by considering almost all examples provided in foundational books - e.g. Stuff. - plausible alternative explanations abound.

Ref also the fact that the primary triad of traits claimed ( emotional attachment to things, difficulty discarding "regardless of actual value" (sic), difficulty making decisions ) was not definitively demonstrated in these books ( to be demonstrated specifically ).

Authors / experts have yet to provide one geniune example of emotional attachment to things in general, representative of the bulk of person's possessions.

Everything seen so far indicates the contrary.